This recipe is a magical blend of sweet and heat for a surprisingly versatile way to can your jalapeños.
This post contains affiliate links, meaning that if you purchase something after clicking on a link in the post I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Heart’s Content Farmhouse is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for website owners to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.
Sometimes I wish I were one of those girls who could talk about growing up on the farm and learning to can and bake alongside their mothers. But my childhood was not like that, and that’s okay. Anyway, the name “cowboy candy” just sounds like something one of those girls would have a good story about. “Oh my mom always used to make cowboy candy for the ranch hands at Christmas and this is her famous recipe” or some tale like that.
My story is not so romantic. I taught myself to garden, and after many years of failure, I successfully grew way too many jalapeños. I taught myself to can, tried and tweaked and perfected this recipe, and shared it with you now. Maybe it’s romantic in its own way. And my girls will have a story.
So what exactly is cowboy candy?
It’s a sliced jalapeños that are briefly cooked in a sugar syrup and then canned. Sounds weird, but it’s delicious. The end result is sweet at first but still retains a lot of heat. You would not want to eat them like candy unless you are a…cowboy.
Some versions of cowboy candy are decidedly savory, and add garlic, onion salt, and things like that. Mine goes more into the sweet side, with cinnamon and ginger, which pair amazingly well with the jalapenos.
And how are you supposed to eat them?
There are so many ways. The most traditional use for them would be poured on top of cream cheese and served as a simple spread with crackers. They are also good chopped up and added to cornbread, served on top of chili, tucked into a grilled cheese sandwich, or used to garnish a cocktail. (This pineapple jalapeno drink looks amazing.)
Tips for working with fresh jalapeños:
- WEAR GLOVES! Oh my goodness, please just do it. When you are slicing this quantity of peppers, you will get the hot oils all over your hands and spread them everywhere.
- If you want to decrease the spiciness of the peppers, you can try removing the seeds, but it is very tedious, and a lot of the heat is in the “membrane” of the pepper. In this recipe, the sugar tones down the heat of the peppers and they will continue to mellow over time.
- Red jalapeños tend to be milder than the green ones. You can’t always find them at the grocery store, but if you grow them in your garden, any jalapeno variety will turn red a week or two after it has grown to its full size. I like to mix red and green when I make cowboy candy for canning, just because I think it is pretty.
Step by step cowboy candy making
If you are going to be waterbath canning these, go ahead and prepare your canner and jars. Wash the jars and put them in the oven or hot water to keep them warm. Get the water boiling in your canner and boil a small pan of water for the lids and rings. Make sure you have all the tools you need ready to go before you start making the cowboy candy.
Gather your peppers. If you have a scale, weigh them. You need 3 pounds. This will equal 8 cups of sliced jalapeños.
Put your gloves on, and get to slicing. I always do this by hand and it doesn’t take that long. Put some music and just do it.
They’re pretty, right? Like little Christmas peppers. You should have about 8 cups of sliced jalapeños. If you don’t have quite that, its totally okay.
Next, we pour the vinegar, sugar, and seasoning into a stock pot or deep sauté pan. You want a wide surface area so that the liquid can reduce and form a syrup. Bring to a boil, and then reduce to a simmer. It will take a while for the liquid to reduce to a syrup, around 5 to 7 minutes. Keep your eye on it so it doesn’t scorch or bubble over.
When it has thickened, add the sliced peppers. Then reduce heat and simmer for five minutes. The sliced jalapeños will change from a fresh green to more of a pea green, like pickles. This will take about five more minutes.
And that’s it! If you don’t want to can them, they can be stored in the refrigerator for up to three months.
To can your candied jalapeños:
If you have never canned anything before, you will want to carefully read this article on home canned food safety.
Now if you want to can them so they are shelf stable, there are a few more steps. Don’t be scared. We are just boiling them in a huge pot of boiling water to kill anything that could spoil them and seal up the jars. No big deal, right?
You can technically use any large pot to waterbacth can, but I like to have one of the classic canners because they are lightweight and fit your rack just right. You can get a pot and accessory set without spending a lot of money.
It is best to have everything ready to go for the canning portion before you start making the actual recipe. So before you chop the peppers, get set up. Make sure your jars and clean, and heat them up, either in the oven on 200 or in a pot of hot water. They don’t need to be sterilized, just hot so that the hot peppers don’t crack them.
In a smaller pan of water, heat the rings and lids. Get your canner out, fill it with water, and start boiling. Then begin the recipe.
After you’ve made the cowboy candy, use a funnel to help you ladle the peppers into the hot jars.
You want to leave a 1/4 inch of headspace, which just means don’t fill them up to the very top, leave a 1/4 inch of room in case they expand in the canner. Use your little tool to push down the peppers and get air bubbles out. Wipe the rims so they are very clean and the lid can seal to them properly.
Remove your lids and rings from the hot water and screw them on “fingertip tight”, which means tightened until you feel a little resistance, but not too much. You could still twist it on or off with just your fingertips.
Then lower the jars into boiling water, cover the pot with the lid, and process for 10 minutes for half pints or 15 minutes for pints. Remove them carefully and set them on a towel to cool. Don’t disturb them while they are cooling, as they need to seal. You will hear a popping sound and the lid will be totally flat.
Here’s the recipe and the video
If you make this recipe, please leave a rating and comment below and let me know how it went!Print
Cowboy Candy for Canning
Candied jalapeños are sweet, hot, and delicious. Pour on top of cream cheese as an appetizer or use as a condiment for almost anything.
- Prep Time: 50 minutes
- Cook Time: 10 minutes
- Total Time: 1 hour
- Yield: 6 half pint jars 1x
- Category: preserving
- Method: canning
- Cuisine: American
- 3 pounds of jalapeno peppers, sliced into 1/4 inch rings (equals 8 cups of sliced jalapeños)
- 1 1/2 cups white vinegar
- 3 cups white sugar
- 1 teaspoon cinnamon
- 1 teaspoon turmeric
- 1 teaspoon ginger
1. Combine vinegar, sugar, and spices in a large stockpot or high sided sauté pan. Bring to a boil over medium high heat. Reduce to low and simmer until the liquid reduces into a sticky syrup, about 5 to 7 minutes. 2. Add the sliced jalapeños. Increase heat to medium high until mixture boils, then reduce to a simmer. Simmer for five minutes. Jalapeños will change color and seem less bright green. 3. Ladle into hot, clean half pint jars with the help of a funnel. Clean the rims of the jars before putting the lids on, and turn them to fingertip tight, Lower into boiling water in a water bath canner and process for ten minutes. Remove from canner and place on a dish towel to cool at room temperature until lids are sealed. After 24 hours, store in a dark place for up to 1 year.
If you don’t want to can: Simply ladle the cowboy candy into clean jars, twist lids on, and allow to cool to room temperature. Refrigerate for up to 3 months.
More gardening and canning:
- If you get interested in canning on a regular basis, I hope you plan for that in your garden and grow fall crops so that you don’t have to do it in the heat of summer.
- Beginner food preservers may like oven dried strawberries, which are simply and don’t require any canning.
- Dill pickle relish is a little more time-consuming but so handy to have on hand.