24 Timeless Old-Fashioned Easter Cookie Recipes You Must Try

36 Shares

These recipes take me back to my childhood, crowded around grandma’s kitchen table with all my cousins. More than just treats—these cookies are a trip down memory lane. So, tie on your apron and find your favorite in this list of old-fashioned Easter cookies.

You’ll find spring flavors, pretty designs, and lots of classic recipes. I hope you discover one you love!

grid of 4 old fashioned easter cookies
Soft white cookies with pistachio pieces, hinting at a creamy and nutty taste experience.

Pistachio Almond Cake Cookies

Imagine cookies so soft they practically melt in your mouth, bursting with the rich taste of almonds and finished with a sprinkle of crunchy, buttery pistachio pieces. That’s exactly what you’re in for with these treats.

Sandwich cookies with a creamy filling, cracked open to showcase the moist texture.

Old-Fashioned Carrot Cake Cookies

If you’re drowning in carrots this season, I’ve got some great news for you. I’ve been diving into my collection of old cookbooks to give traditional carrot cake recipes a modern twist. The result? My family can’t get enough of these classic carrot cake cookies, slathered in creamy cream cheese icing.

Soft, frosted cookies adorned with multicolored sprinkles, nestled in green paper shreds that mimic grass. The pastel icing and bright sprinkles give the cookies a festive, Easter look.Soft, frosted cookies adorned with multicolored sprinkles, nestled in green paper shreds that mimic grass. The pastel icing and bright sprinkles give the cookies a festive, Easter look.

Italian Easter Cookies

These classic Italian Easter cookies are a real treat, with their zesty lemon flavor, sweet glaze, and colorful sprinkles that scream spring. They’re my go-to when the family comes around for Easter, offering that perfect blend of tradition and fun. Plus, they’re easy enough that the kids can get in on the action, rolling them out and adding that final, sweet drizzle.

close up view of buttercream thumbprint cookies on rack.

Buttercream Thumbprint Cookies

A buttery cookie base and luscious, creamy filling.

A close-up of blondie bars with chunks of white chocolate and bits of red fruit, stacked on a plate. The bars have a dense, chewy texture, typical of blondies, with visible pieces of mix-ins that add color and texture.

Strawberries and Cream Cookie Bars

Picture this: chewy bits of strawberry and chunks of creamy white chocolate dotted through soft, buttery squares of cookie heaven. It’s like starting with the ultimate chocolate chip cookie dough and then throwing in a few delightful curveballs with fruity bites and chocolatey goodness.

Round cookies with a dollop of dark jam in the center, resting on a cooling rack with a jar of jam in the background. The jam centers give the cookies a jewel-like appearance, reminiscent of classic thumbprint cookies.

Lemon Blueberry Cookies

Dive into the delightful world of blueberry thumbprint cookies, where the buttery goodness of shortbread meets the sweet tang of homemade jam. What’s even better is how straightforward this recipe is, making it a fantastic choice for those just starting their baking adventure.

Close-up of a coconut-topped cookie with chocolate swirls, suggesting a chewy texture with sweet and rich flavors.

Chewy Coconut Chocolate Chip Cookies

These Chewy Coconut Chocolate Chip Cookies are slightly crispy on the outside and chewy soft on the inside. The flavors of coconut and chocolate makes them irresistible.

Elegant cookies decorated with lavender icing and drizzle, suggesting a delicate floral note in the flavor.

Earl Grey Shortbread Cookies

With just five ingredients, this simple Earl Grey shortbread features sweet citrus flavour with a hint of black tea. Just right for an afternoon treat! This is an easy recipe but the dough needs to be chilled, so be sure to plan a bit in advance.

Rustic cookies with a hole at one end, threaded with string, presented in a basket alongside a bunch of white daisies. The cookies have a homemade, country-style charm, evoking a sense of spring or Easter celebration.

Chamomile Tea Shortbread Cookies

Elevate your tea time with these exquisite chamomile tea shortbread cookies. Their light, floral chamomile flavor pairs beautifully with the rich, buttery texture and a zesty hint of lemon, making them the perfect companion for your tea or latte. It’s the afternoon pick-me-up you’ve been dreaming of.

A stack of pink-flecked cookies with a single cookie resting in front, showcasing a vibrant burst of berry flavor.

Lemon Raspberry Cookies

Get ready for a burst of sunshine in cookie form with these Raspberry Cookies. They’re soft, light, and packed with the vibrant flavors of fresh lemon and raspberries. Plus, they’re a breeze to whip up, ensuring they’re a hit with everyone who tries them.

Round cookies with white glaze and red sprinkled accents resting on a cooling rack, hinting at a sweet strawberry flavor.

White Chocolate Strawberry Shortbread Cookies

Welcome spring with these gorgeous white chocolate strawberry shortbread cookies. With their soft, buttery base, bits of freeze-dried strawberries, and a drizzle of sweet white chocolate, these cookies are as beautiful as they are delicious. And the best part? They don’t spread, so each one comes out perfect.

Simple round sugar cookies with sparkling granulated sugar on top, presented on a vintage-style plate, suggesting a classic treat.

Lemon Snap Cookies from 1881

Whipping up these cookies is a piece of cake, and they’ll stay fresh for ages. Just heat your oven up nice and hot, and go easy on the flour. I’ve found that one cup plus two tablespoons is the sweet spot, with just a smidge more for dusting. And a teaspoon of lemon essence gives them that perfect zing.

Round cookies with a golden edge and a sprinkle of yellow on top, possibly with a hint of floral notes, presented on a rustic fabric.

Shortbread Dandelion Cookies Recipe

In the mood to shake things up with a unique cookie recipe? Let me introduce you to something a bit wild: shortbread dandelion cookies. Trust me, you’ve gotta try them.

Snowball-like cookies dusted with powdered sugar on a bright background, giving a sense of a sweet, melt-in-your-mouth texture.

Lemon Snowball Cookies

These lemon snowballs, also known as wedding cookies, are the epitome of holiday treats. Imagine rich, buttery cookies with a zesty kick, so delicate they dissolve the moment they hit your tongue. Coated in powdered sugar, they look just like little snowballs and usually come packed with pecans or walnuts for that irresistible crumbly texture.

Pink glazed cookies topped with a cherry, set on a wire cooling rack, hinting at a sweet, fruit-infused flavor.

Old Fashioned Cherry Bonbon Cookies

Cherry bonbon cookies are like a trip down memory lane—buttery, sweet, and perfectly crisp, with a juicy maraschino cherry waiting at the center. They’re a nod to old-fashioned shortbread, with just a hint of vanilla and almond, all topped off with cherry-flavored icing. And the best part? You only need one bowl to make them, plus they’re dairy-free, vegan, and eggless!

Oatmeal cookies with chocolate candies and nuts, displayed on a polka dot plate.

Creme Egg Cookies

If you’re after a cookie that really packs a punch, you have to try these Creme Egg Cookies. Loaded with dark chocolate, pecans, and oats, and crowned with a mini Creme Egg, they’re the perfect blend of crispy and chewy. But be warned: they’re so tasty, they won’t stick around for long!

Elegant cookies decorated with pink icing shaped like flowers on top, exuding a sense of springtime and festivity.

Pretty, Pastel Springtime Cookies

These delicate floral cookies are just the thing for your Easter celebration. Here’s a neat trick: you can prep and decorate them up to a week in advance. Just fill them with jam when you’re ready to serve or share them as gifts.

A selection of pale, intricately embossed cookies cooling on a wire rack. The cookies are in various shapes, including hearts and leaves, and feature detailed patterns that give them a vintage, handcrafted look.

Old-Fashioned Maple Syrup Cookies

Indulge in the classic taste of butter cookies, elevated with a touch of maple for a delightful twist!

Bunny-shaped sugar cookies with white and pink icing details

Easter Sugar Cookies

Whip up some joy with adorable Bunny Cookies. These sugar cookies aren’t just tasty; they’re also a feast for the eyes with their cute bunny designs and vibrant icing. Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, or a festive Easter treat, these cookies will add a dash of sweetness to any event.

Traditional powdered sugar-dusted cookies, with a nutty filling, arranged in a ceramic bowl.

Mexican Wedding Cookies

Mexican Wedding Cookies are tender, buttery delights that literally melt in your mouth. These cookies, brimming with a rich, nutty flavor and filled with pecans, are dusted with powdered sugar for a festive touch. No wedding necessary to enjoy these celebratory treats – they’re as thrilling as falling in love!

A row of round cookies with a delicate drizzle of pink icing on a white surface, suggesting a sweet and festive treat.

Tangy and Soft Rhubarb Cookies

When rhubarb season hits, I go all in and whip up everything rhubarb I can think of. These tangy, soft rhubarb cookies lived up to all my expectations and more.

Close-up of round cookies topped with a thick white icing, placed on a cooling rack, evoking a homemade and comforting vibe.

Old Fashioned Pineapple Cookies

Pineapple lovers, take note! These Old Fashioned Pineapple Cookies, packed with crushed pineapple and crowned with a vanilla pineapple frosting, are a tropical dream come true.

Delicate, flower-shaped cookies with a glossy lemon icing, garnished with lemon zest and small white flowers. The cookies are styled with a half-slice of lemon and black specks, possibly vanilla or poppy seeds, in the background.

Lemon Shortbread Cookies

Lemon Shortbread Cookies are not only quick and easy to make but also divinely melt-in-your-mouth delicious. The zesty lemon twist makes them a fabulous addition to any holiday spread, whether it’s a spring birthday, Easter, or just because.

Traditional twisted cookies displayed on a plate with a red background, offering a homemade, comforting appeal.

Greek Easter Cookies

Dive into the tradition of Koulourakia Paschalina, the Greek Easter cookies known for their crispy exterior and soft, orange-flavored interior. They’re an ideal companion for your coffee or tea break.

More Pretty Easter Desserts

If cakes and cobblers are more your thing, you’ll love these beautiful springtime desserts, perfect to serve to afternoon guests or at Easter dinner.

I hope you’ve found inspiration in the simplicity and charm of these delightful treats. Whether you choose to follow the recipes to the letter or add your own creative twist, there’s something perfect here for you this spring!

24 Timeless Old-Fashioned Easter Cookie Recipes You Must Try
36 Shares

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *