A look at extreme couponing and if it’s worth the time it takes. My own experience couponing, and why I eventually stopped.
I used to be an extreme couponer. I was good at it. I had envelopes of CVS receipts showing totals of $0.00 for people who didn’t believe me. I stopped in 2014 and I just opened my last package of Venus razors that I got for free. (December of 2012 the good times were really rolling on the Venus razor deals.)
I regularly took home free toiletries, medicine, snacks, cereal, and candy. I would only get toothpaste if it was a moneymaker because I had so much. (That means your coupon is more than you are paying, and you end up getting store credit for purchasing it.).
I saved a lot of money with extreme couponing over the years
But after about six years of it, I stopped.
I didn’t have any ethical issues with it, which a lot of people bring up. You are just combining sales, store coupons, and manufacturers coupons. The store gets reimbursed from the manufacturer. People are getting compensated.
I also didn’t have the problem that there are no coupons for real foods. I stuck to drugstores and mostly came home with toiletries, and the occasional packaged snack.
Extreme couponing was not worth it for me in the end
Extreme couponing is very aptly named. It is extreme.
There is no way to get stuff for free by casually couponing. Sure you can get a dollar off your grocery bill here and there by clipping what appeals to you in the Sunday paper. That is casual couponing. I would laugh at that.
Extreme couponing involves researching, keeping a binder, rolling over deals, and always, always, planning. There is writing to companies asking for coupons, and even buying coupons when you were planning a huge buy of something.
You need to be checking ads and websites constantly. I would be up late at night, reading forums. Topics like “when will the March finish dish tabs coupon date be announced?”, and “CVS Trip Report, $18 Moneymaker!”. I posted too. (My favorite sub forum was Kmart. They doubled coupons up to and including one full dollar and ran very good promotions on top of that.)
There is also no way to do it without keeping a stockpile. The way it works, especially with drugstores, is you are rolling over your store credit (“extra bucks” and similarly named things) to get more things that also generate credit. They expire. You have to keep doing it. Even if there is nothing you want that week.
You couldn’t get the best deals unless you went to the drugstores on Sunday mornings. As it turns out, going to CVS, Rite Aid, and Walgreens at 7 on a Sunday morning to buy a bunch of junk does not exactly align with my vision for our family.
After the Sunday buying-fest early in the morning, you get to look at store ads and coupons in the Sunday paper for the next week. I remember Maddie, as a baby, being so interested in those shiny little rectangles I had put in piles, and me pushing her away so I could plan my shopping trip. It makes me quite seriously want to cry. Did I need all of this that badly?
Extreme couponing kept me in the consumption mindset, and I wanted my life to be something different.
Now I am not opposed to working a bit to save money, but this was weird. I got really obsessed with it. I lived for the reaction of the cashiers, who I’m sure hated me. I talked about it. A lot. I loved showing off my stockpile and my receipts. Also, it was not like cooking or gardening, things that you can do with the kids and teach them about. It was just shopping.
As someone who loves to spend money, it was a way to indulge my consumerism without paying the dollars and cents price. But I was still paying the price. I was obsessed with getting things, arranging my things, talking about my things. There was so much excess on my shelves, I would throw out unfinished body wash bottles because I wanted to move on to a new scent. Hey why not, I would think, it was free. It was like quitting smoking and constantly chewing nicotine gum for the rest of your life.
Looking back on my extreme couponing days, it was not worth the energy, the time, or the weirdness.
I did not make a conscious decision to quit, I just stopped little by little. My reasons were practical, not moral. I had my second baby and it was harder to get out of the house. Our Kmart closed. I got pickier about products I wanted to buy, only liking certain brands. We moved to a very small house without rooms to store cubic yards of free shampoo. It is only now, looking back, that I see how silly and sad it was.
I still enjoy a good deal at the store, and will stock up within reason when there is a sale. But thinking about couponing feels gross to me now. An obsession with acquiring a bunch of stuff. Things stored in weird places, like cereal under the bed. The time that my children were babies that I will never get back. The huge binder. The rush of walking out of a store, laden with bags.
I don’t know what deals are out there any more. I just buy the Kirkland brand of everything at Costco. There is a lot of new body wash I will never smell, and weird, new candy I will never taste, and I’m okay with that.
My husband is running low on shampoo, so while I was at the grocery store I spent $5.99 on a full priced bottle of Head and Shoulders. I would regularly get this for pennies back in the day. I just put it in my cart and moved on with my life.
And that part didn’t seem like such a bad deal.
13 thoughts on “Is Extreme Couponing Worth It?”
After reading your story about extreme couponing, it reminded me of the folks who sit in their driveway (yard sales) or flea market every weekend trying to make a buck on their over stocked items. The items are displayed in all types of weather and the folks selling their overstocked items look tired. Not my cup of tea.
What a fascinating share. I once (briefly) thought about doing extreme couponing – thankful that never gained traction for me! Thank you for your story, Katie. This site is fun and a breath of fresh air. Blessings!
I never participated in *extreme* couponing, buy did have an Avery binder for the coupons I intended to use. I saved tons of money, although ultimately stopped couponing when the coupons available started to move away from things I regularly used and were only for pushing new products or items I did not use.
I ultimately found that it saved me as much if not more money to track the sales and learn how frequently items I purchase go on sale. Now, when a sale hits I stock up on enough to get me through till the next sale. It helps, of course, that I have a deep freezer and extra storage space.
Yes! I think of that as smart shopping. Not too extreme and you know that you will actually use everything you buy.
Great post, but reading it made me tired! Ok everything makes me tired anymore! It sounds like a crazy life! Glad you were able to kick the habit!
Haha for some reason this comment cracked me up. You have a good excuse to be tired ????
Loved your thoughts on this! I fell down the couponing rabbit hole around 2012 too, although I was never very good at it, hah! I was always so impressed with the deals other people found, but I don’t think I spent nearly enough time on it to see the real benefits.
Don’t be impressed! We were all just a bunch of crazies! ????
Ah yes. I too had my binder days. I would get aggravated with my husband for not wanting to save more money when he was just miserable to help me cut a thousand coupons.
We all make mistakes, the beauty is that we learned through the lesson. I find that I still try to get the head and shoulders at Target when they go on sale for buy the 4 get the $5 gift card. But even then our life is not over when he needs facewash at full price. I stockpile within reason for food sales but even then I have my limits. I do believe you have a great understanding in moving from extremism to simplicity.
My husband was all about it! It was probably my only hobby that he actually was impressed with. ????. Not sure what that says about us!?
Haha a supportive husband who loves to see his wife succeed says that your marriage is healthy. 🙂
I feel like extreme cuponing is very closely related to Hoarding (the actual condition) even though few- if any- really ever make that connection… But that’s essentially what you’re doing under the guise of “good” (in much the same way Orthorexia is still an eating disorder despite only eating “healthy” food). It seems healthy & like it actually saves you money. But it’s not & really doesn’t at all.
It’s so true! Imagine a hoarder saying “but all this stuff was free!”. Right… it’s still a bunch of junk destroying your life!