17 Old-Fashioned Valentine’s Day Candies To Make at Home {Nostalgic + Delicious}

Remember those heart-shaped candies and homemade fudges that made Valentine’s Day special? Well, they’re making a comeback! We’re bringing back the classics. These charming, nostalgic recipes have been passed down through generations. Sweet, beautiful, and perfect for giving to someone special… or enjoying yourself.

Hope you love these old-fashioned Valentine’s Day candy recipes ❤️.

grid of 6 valentine  candies

So, get ready to step into a world where traditional flavors meet timeless love. We’re about to rediscover the magic of homemade candy. It’s just in time to make this Valentine’s Day extra special and sweet!

Pieces of dark chocolate bark topped with crushed cookies, nuts, and red and pink sprinkles.

Valentine’s Easy Toffee Recipe

Try out this Simple and Quick Toffee Recipe, ideal for Valentine’s Day! It’s not only a breeze to whip up but also makes a delightful snack or a charming gift for someone special.

Grandma’s Old Fashioned Fudge {Classic Stovetop recipe}

How to make fudge the old-fashioned way: just minutes of your time plus a few dollars of pantry ingredients gives you a candy shop quality homemade chocolate fudge perfect for gifting (or keeping!)

Red cinnamon-flavored broken hard candy pieces dusted with powdered sugar.

Stained Glass Candy Recipe

Stained Glass Candy is both a treat for the taste buds and a feast for the eyes. Its shattered pieces resemble beautiful stained glass shards, adding an artistic touch. You can get creative with almost any flavor and color, but there’s something special about the fiery red cinnamon rock candy – it’s my absolute favorite! And the best part? It’s surprisingly simple to make, perfect for adding a unique twist to your Valentine’s Day celebrations.

Layered chocolate and vanilla fudge with almond pieces on a wooden cutting board.

Nut Goodie Fudge

Nut Goodie Fudge is a timeless recipe that captures hearts every time it’s made. Once you try it, you’ll find yourself coming back to it repeatedly. It’s been a Christmas favorite for us, but it’s just as delightful for Valentine’s Day. This homemade fudge, with its irresistible layers of chocolate, vanilla, and peanuts, is the kind of treat that’s hard to say no to!

White chocolate peanut butter balls with pink sprinkles and white drizzle.

Valentine’s Day No-Bake Peanut Butter Balls

These No-Bake Peanut Butter Balls are a perfect treat for Valentine’s Day. Dipped in luscious white chocolate and adorned with festive Valentine’s Day sprinkles, they’re not only delightful but also require no baking at all! A sweet and simple way to celebrate love.

Classic Vanilla Fudge Recipe

Homemade vanilla fudge on the stovetop made with simple ingredients: in just an hour you can have candy-shop quality rich fudge.

Chocolate candies in a green bowl, generously covered with multicolored nonpareil sprinkles.

Chocolate Nonpareils Candy

Homemade Chocolate Nonpareils are a delightful confection consisting of rich chocolate discs, each topped with a colorful coating of rainbow nonpareil sprinkles on one side. They’re a charming and tasty treat, perfect for any occasion.

Valentine’s Day Fudge

Indulge in this rich White Chocolate Fudge recipe, a perfect sweet treat for celebrating Valentine’s Day. It’s as luxurious and delicious, making it a wonderful way to add a touch of romance to your day.

Old-Fashioned Soft Stovetop Caramels

The best homemade soft and chewy caramel candies! With simple ingredients and a little patience, you'll be enjoying gourmet, buttery caramels.

White chocolate-coated lemon truffles dusted with powdered sugar.

White Chocolate Lemon Truffles

These Creamy White Chocolate Lemon Truffles are delicious and different. They’re perfect for gifting or tucking inside a box of mixed Valentine’s goodies. With their delightful combination of flavors, they’re bound to become a new favorite.

Chocolate truffles in a heart-shaped box, each topped with a tiny pink heart.

Chocolate Truffles

Homemade Chocolate Truffles feature a delicate chocolate shell encasing a luxuriously smooth chocolate center that melts in your mouth. They’re an ideal gift to show love.

Squares of pink white chocolate fudge with red candy pieces on top.

Valentine’s Day Nougat Candy

If you’re on the hunt for a straightforward yet delightful treat for Valentine’s Day, this Valentine’s Day Nougat Candy Recipe is just the thing! It’s not only delicious but also incredibly easy to whip up.

Red sugar-coated gummy candies in ring and disc shapes on a wooden surface.

Homemade Valentine’s Day Gumdrops

Making your own Valentine’s candy at home is a blast with this Homemade Valentine Gum Drops Recipe. It’s a fun and creative way to add a personal touch to your Valentine’s Day celebrations right from your kitchen.

Dark chocolate-covered cherries with stems on a white plate.

Cherry Cordials

Craft classic Cherry Cordials right in your own kitchen! With a combination of cherries, Kirschwasser, and rich dark chocolate, these treats are the ultimate candy delight. Discover the secrets to creating the authentic cordial-syrup filling that makes them so special.

Golden brown pieces of sucre à la crème on a white background.

Sucre à la Creme

Sucre à la Creme, a beloved sweet delicacy from Quebec, Canada, is a favorite during the holiday season. It’s an ideal treat for anyone with a sweet tooth.

Chunks of chocolate fudge with whole peanuts and marshmallows.

Heavenly Hash Candy

This candy recipe is not only easy to follow but also perfect for creating delightful Christmas gifts. It’s advisable to store it in the refrigerator, as the chocolate tends to soften at room temperature. Though the taste remains delicious even when it’s soft.

Slices of toffee sprinkled with finely chopped nuts on a white plate.

Buttery English Toffee Candy

English Toffee in its finest form is a symphony of crunchy, buttery goodness, crowned with a smooth layer of chocolate and a sprinkle of almond meal. It’s also surprisingly simple to make with just seven ingredients.

More resources:

Don’t forget to wrap up your confections with care, store them properly, and if you’re sharing them, do so with a generous heart. So, whether these treats end up on your table or are shared with someone special, they are bound to be a hit.

AnyDesign Valentine's Day Kitchen Towel 18 x 28 Buffalo Plaids Love Heart Dish Towel Romantic Sweet Hand Drying Towel Tea Towel for Wedding Anniversary Cooking Baking, Set of 2AnyDesign Valentine’s Day Kitchen Towel 18 x 28 Buffalo Plaids Love Heart Dish Towel Romantic Sweet Hand Drying Towel Tea Towel for Wedding Anniversary Cooking Baking, Set of 2BadenBach 50 Pack Small Rectangle Kraft Paper Boxes with Clear Windows,3.33BadenBach 50 Pack Small Rectangle Kraft Paper Boxes with Clear Windows,3.33G2PLUS Christmas String,Gift Wrapping String,2MM White and Red Twine String,328Feet Cotton Natural String Butchers Twine for Gift Packaging,Baking,DIY Arts & CraftsG2PLUS Christmas String,Gift Wrapping String,2MM White and Red Twine String,328Feet Cotton Natural String Butchers Twine for Gift Packaging,Baking,DIY Arts & Crafts


Happy Valentine’s Day, and happy candy-making! I hope your day be filled with love, laughter, and the sweet satisfaction of a homemade treat. 🍬

17 Old-Fashioned Valentine\'s Day Candies To Make at Home {Nostalgic + Delicious}
Click here to subscribe

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *